VAR Controversy Erupts Over Bruno Fernandes’ Goal in Manchester United’s Win Against Chelsea

The Premier League has released the VAR images of Bruno Fernandes’ opening goal in Manchester United’s 2-1 victory over Chelsea, sparking heated debate among fans and pundits. The goal came shortly after Chelsea goalkeeper Robert Sánchez was dismissed for a late challenge on Bryan Mbeumo, leaving the visitors down to ten men.

Former goalkeeper Shay Given, speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live, voiced doubts about the legitimacy of the strike.

> “The angle I’ve seen, he looked offside if I’m being honest…” Given remarked, pointing out the timing of the pass. While Benjamin Šeško appeared in an offside position, Fernandes seemed to have been played onside by Trevoh Chalobah, who stepped up late.

The Premier League’s decision to publish the VAR stills only intensified the controversy. Fans flooded social media with complaints about the ruling, many claiming Fernandes was “clearly offside.” Some highlighted the peculiar placement of the offside line, with one frustrated supporter writing: “Never in my life seen a line that high on the shoulder?” Another added: “Are you not offside from the sleeve?”

The match’s drama escalated further when Casemiro received a second yellow card just before half-time, reducing United to ten men. Sky Sports pundit Alan Smith criticized the Brazilian’s first booking as “silly,” insisting his actions “made life unnecessarily difficult for his team.”

Between Sánchez’s early dismissal, Fernandes’ disputed opener, and Casemiro’s sending off, the game became a showcase of contentious refereeing calls that overshadowed much of the football. The fallout has reignited debates about VAR consistency and the broader impact of officiating decisions on high-stakes fixtures.

As the dust settles, both clubs will reflect on how these pivotal moments shaped the match—and how similar controversies continue to shape the narrative of the Premier League season.